Catholic Central’s Herder, 11 more introduced as new wrestling coaches

INTRODUCING — The Ohio Valley Athletic Conference welcomed a dozen new coaches to the wrestling family during a press conference Monday inside WesBanco Arena. Among those on hand were, from left, front, Justin Herder (Catholic Central), Brian Bullock (Dover), Jeff Parsons (Warren Local), Jonny McComas (Beaver Local) and Cameron Phillips (Hundred assistant); back, Ernie VanDyne (Beallsville), Jimmy Malone (Southern Local), Adam Hicks (New Philadelphia assistant), Dan Kelch (Hundred) and Ryan Asbury (John Marshall). Mike Rose (Bellaire), Zack Patterson (Meadowbrook) and Luke Spencer (Edison) also are new coaches. -- Kim North

WHEELING — There’s an old adage that if something isn’t broke, don’t fix it. Well, that might be true most of the time, but sometimes change can be for the better.

The Ohio Valley Athletic Conference Ron Mauck wrestling tournament has been a staple of mid-January for the past six-and-a-half decades. Come year 66, it will have undergone a major change proposed by conference coaches.

During the preseason meeting Monday night inside WesBanco Arena, it was voted upon that a seven-member committee will determine the way wrestlers are seeded for the 2020 three-day event. Forty-two of the conference’s 44 head coaches in attendance participated and voted 29-13 for the change. Edison and Wellsville were not represented. The new format will be under a three-year tenure to start.

“It will be done by a committee for the first time,” tournament director Dan Doyle said.

Is it good or bad?

“It’s going to be interesting. I think the coaches over the years have done a fantastic job, and I think the statistics show that,” he said. “I think sometimes where a wrestler was seeded wasn’t the most accurate, but if they were in the top eight (when the tournament began), 90-95 percent of them were on the podium come Saturday night.

“Times change. Many, many major tournaments around the country are now being seeded by committees for multiple reasons.”

He said doing it this way will allow for the coaches to be able to spend more time with their families.

“We used to do it in two days. On the Sunday before the tournament the coaches would all come together at the arena for the seeding meeting, and then the following Monday they would all come back for the press conference,” Doyle said. “Now, the seeding committee will do its work on Sunday and will come in Monday with the coaches.

“Coaches, as everybody does, have so many responsibilities nowadays, so a seven-person committee, five of whom are coaches and a pair of ‘professionals.’ One of the criteria to be eligible is a coach must have been a head coach for at least five years.”

Jesse Wells, representing the OVAC Wrestling Coaches Association, agreed with Doyle.

“I think it’s a great idea. Obviously, whenever you do something new there are going to be hiccups along the way, but I genuinely think it’s taking a step in the right direction,” said Wells, the head coach at Shenandoah.

“I think the intentions are good. You’re putting the future of the tournament in capable hands. I think it will streamline the process and only make it better.”

If a coach desires to serve on the committee, they need to submit an application by Nov. 18, along with five other coaches signing on that they feel this person would represent all of the wrestlers in the conference, not just their individual teams. All successful applicants must serve a three-year term.

“Then, our (OVAC Ron Mauck) tournament committee will gather the first of December. From the list of applicants, our committee will select five coaches,” Doyle said. “We will be looking at representation from both states in which the conference serves, geographically in the conference, and by class.

“It’s going to be interesting. Jeff Crosier, who serves on the tournament committee, does a great job with all of our statistics. It should be interesting to see how it plays out.”

In addition to Doyle and Crosier, the tournament committee includes tournament namesake Ron Mauck, former Shadyside successful head coach Sean Grinch and Rich McCardle, a long-time tournament fixture.

Also comprising the seven-member panel will be “professionals” Jim Rocchi and Sean Smith.


“We’re going to give it another shot,” Kelch said. “We’ve got 18 kids out right now, but after the first week we’ll see what happens.”

It’s been 20 years since he coached.

“My son, Jeremy Kelch, is the athletic director and he came to me and wanted to know if we wanted to start a wrestling team back up,” Kelch said. “I told him if I had some help, we would try and undertake it and see what we can do.”

Hundred has hired Cameron Phillips as the assistant to Kelch. The Hornets have about 10 matches scheduled thus far.

“Again, another small school,” Doyle said. “I know they had some good numbers sign up, so if they can keep at least half of those kids, that would be a very successful year for them.”


A pair of “big schools” also have joined the conference, those being Dover and New Philadelphia. Both programs have storied wrestling histories and should bring some good competition.

Warren Local, which joined the conference a few years back, will be wrestling an OVAC schedule this winter. The Warriors also will compete in the OVAC Ron Mauck tournament for the first time.


Clay-Battelle has dropped the sport for the upcoming season.


In addition to Hundred, Dover (Brian Bullock), New Philadelphia (Cory Swinderman) and Warren Local (Jeff Parsons) will be making their initial appearances in the OVAC, making a dozen new head coaches for this season.

It is a list that includes Ernie VanDyne (Beallsville), Jonny McComas (Beaver Local), Mike Rose (Bellaire), Luke Spencer (Edison), Ryan Asbury (John Marshall), Zack Patterson (Meadowbrook), Jimmy Malone (Southern Local) and Justin Herder (Catholic Central).


¯ The OVAC Ron Mauck tournament will be held from Jan. 16-18 at WesBanco Arena.

¯ The OVAC Bill Hinegardner Duals will be held on Jan. 29 for the Class 3A and Class 5A semifinalists at the John Marshall Fieldhouse in Moundsville.

Meanwhile, the Class 1A/2A and Class 4A qualifiers will meet the next night at Brooke High School.


Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)


Starting at $4.39/week.

Subscribe Today