Trending
STEUBENVILLE -- Frustrations boiled over at City Council Tuesday after a council member requested they do some housekeeping with their weekly agenda.
Third Ward Councilwoman Heather Hoover said a list of 10 tabled ordinances at the bottom of their agendas were a reminder that "we're just not moving forward."
"We're saying parks and recreation is vital to our community and we're not moving forward on any project," she said. "So, I mean, if we could get them off the table at some point, I mean I'd love to do that, and start fresh."
Eight of the tabled items date to August 2022, when Fourth Ward Councilman Royal Mayo proposed earmarking more than $3 million for parks and recreation, and $700,000 for the planning and zoning commission for development of "various projects" across the city.
Two other tabled ordinances proposed creating a community improvement corporation and seeking proposals for professional engineering design services for lighting Belleview Park ball fields.
"I'm not saying I support all of these or I support any of them or I'm opposed to all of them, but considering we're going to have at least two new members (in January), even if we un-table all of them and they all fail they can be reintroduced," she said. "We could just start over with a fresh new perspective. I've been sitting here for nine months and I'm tired of looking at them. I feel like we're not moving forward on these.”
Sixth Ward Councilman Mike Hernon pointed out most, if not all, of the 10 tabled ordinances "didn't come from the parks and recreation department, they didn't come from the parks and recreation board or the committee, that's why they were tabled."
"To me, it's a question of getting the parks board, the parks department to vet them," he said.
Mayo bristled, lamenting council members have no real say on appointments to city boards and insisting those boards are "there to advise us, not direct us."
"We don't have to take the advice that they gave," Mayo snapped. "So if a council person wants to sunshine an ordinance or money to be allocated, that's what we're there for -- not to be directed by a body I have no ability to pick or choose."
By charter, the mayor brings his recommendation for board members to council, who then vote on them.
Hernon pointed out that board members "are empowered by us" to make recommendations to council.
The meeting devolved, with council members interrupting each other and speaking without being recognized by the chair. At one point Mayo moved to bring a proposal to fund improvements to batting cages and ball fields back to the floor and got a second, then tried to do the same for another item before being reminded that they couldn't do anything else without voting on his first motion.
Fifth Ward Councilman Willie Paul originally said he would vote no so they could meet with the recreation board before making any decisions, but when Councilwoman at large Kimberly Hahn reminded him they've already scheduled a meeting with the planning commission prior to next Monday’s meeting and suggested delaying it until the following week so the rec board could meet.
"We're just throwing things out on that," he said. "We don't know where we're at."
With that, Paul joined Hoover, Mayo and First Ward Councilwoman Asantewa Anyabwile in voting to withdraw the measure from the table and bring it back to council floor where it will have to be amended, since the ballfield upgrades have already been completed.
Mayo then proposed pulling a proposal to fund repairs to the Beatty Park Bridge back to council floor, pointing out they'd already funded that project.
"This vote is to eliminate it?" Hoover asked.
"No, it's to get it off the table," Paul replied.
After more back and forth, Second Ward Councilman Tracy McManamon asked, "Did anyone second that motion? I'm losing track."
"We don't know what we're doing," a frustrated Hahn agreed. "We're speaking out of turn, we need some guidance from the law director to know exactly what it is that we're actually voting on and get more information. We're just shooting from the hip, which is exactly how we got in this place in the first place -- (the tabled items) didn't come through any committees, they didn't come from a normal process."
"It didn't come from committee because you're the chairman, you've got the deck stacked," Mayo said. "You're not going to sunshine anything for the 4th Ward so I did it myself. So now you know."
Council voted 4-3 to return the proposal to fund Beatty Park improvements back to the floor so it can be disposed of.
Hahn, Hernon and McManamon all voted no, with McManamon saying he voted that way "because I think this process is absolutely the wrong way to do it."
Paul consoled him, saying, "We have three weeks now to get an answer to you. …"
"If we're going to introduce ordinances and then table them, then we should probably know what we're going to do with them after we table them," Hoover added.